Today NBC and the Wall Street Journal released a new survey conducted by the polling company Hart/McInturff. MSNBC.com’s deputy political director, Mark Murray writes,
The GOP’s ‘likely’ advantage
In the survey, 50 percent of likely voters say they prefer a Republican-controlled Congress, versus 43 percent who want Democrats in charge.
Last month, Republicans held a 46 percent to 43 percent advantage among likely voters on this question.
The GOP’s current seven-point lead, McInturff observes, is on pace — historically — to result in a shift of power in Congress. “The Democrats, with two weeks left, are facing very, very difficult arithmetic.”
Yet among the wider universe of registered voters, Democrats hold a two-point edge, 46 to 44 percent, which is up from the 44 percent to 44 percent tie in September.
But Hart calls that lead “hollow,” because not all registered voters will participate, especially in a midterm election.
Indeed, among those expressing a high interest in voting this midterm season, Republicans hold a 13-point advantage on the generic ballot, 53 percent to 40 percent.
So, as I often do, I clicked on the link to the published survey results and read it through looking for the results described in the article. First time through I thought I missed this 50% to 43% advantage of the Republicans over the Democrats. So I read it again, now looking line by line where that percentage comparison came up. I couldn’t find it. Okay, so one more time, very deliberately reading through the survey. Nada. What I did discover were two very interesting questions that belie a different mood in the electorate.
Keep in mind this was a survey of 1000 registered voters, which, as I have explained in previous posts, I hold to the theory that registered voters provide a more reliable sample and predictor of which way the election is more likely to go. In two weeks we’ll know.
Let’s look first at question Q11a:
Q11a: What is your preference for the outcome of this year’s congressional elections — (ROTATE:) a Congress controlled by Republicans or a Congress controlled by Democrats?
The result favors the Democrats 46% to Republicans 44%. That is mentioned in the quote above. It’s also within the published margin of error of +/- 3.10%. One could say, therefore, it’s a wash, but there is some interesting info in the trends. The median (the midpoint of the 11 surveys NBC/WSJ has conducted since January 2010 for the Republicans is 44% and the Democrats, 43%. Now that is tight! The slope of those eleven surveys for this question is also small, 0.21% for the GOP and 0.25% for the Dems. Not what you might write home about. But still, when you apply those numbers to tens of millions of voters, small changes can make the difference. It also shows that the Democrats are perhaps not in quite as bad a shape as the pundits have been droning on about month after month.
But there is more. Question Q12A reads:
Q12a: If you had the choice in your congressional district, would you be more likely to vote for a (ROTATE:) Republican, Democratic, Libertarian, or Green Party candidate for Congress?
Since the smaller party candidates are at best wild cards, we can’t make a prediction if those who claim affiliation will actually vote for them. But here, we find the responses again favor the Democrats over the Republicans, 44% to 41%. Unfortunately, the survey does not provide the historical results of this question.
If you have looked at the published survey results, you might have noticed a number of questions are missing. So, we can perhaps infer that NBC and the WSJ decided the most interesting information in the survey they wanted to keep to themselves, which is their prerogative since they paid for it. And perhaps that 50% Republican advantage is among those survey items that were, shall we say, redacted. But if the Democrats are in such dire shape going into the election and the survey shows that is very clear, why bother with cutting questions out of the published report? Wouldn’t a reasonable person, or especially a partisan one, such as the Wall Street Journal’s clear editorial preference for Conservatives, want that information right there for everyone to see? I can’t answer that question, but I do find it perplexing.
Nevertheless, there is enough information to ponder the strength of the GOP’s “surge” as reported. My updated graph with the trend lines still shows the Democrats in a stronger growth curve:
Registered Voters Surveys 18 Oct 10. Data Courtesy HuffPost Pollster
I will be eagerly looking forward to the next batch of polls to be released. Each data point provides a world of information about might or can happen on November 2nd.