Last One Out, Please Close the Gate
Last night, local time in the Middle East at a border crossing between Iraq and Kuwait, the last Stryker Brigade of American Combat troops rolled through the gates ending seven years of United States military operations. The combat role is finished and has been turned over to the Iraqi military. Although the Stryker Brigade is being processed for their first day in Kuwait, a substantial force of non-combat military personnel remain, some 50,000 we are told.
Is the war over? Did we win?
The hope is that the combat part of the war is over. The so-called advisors will have many roles, from training to consultation, to building ongoing relations with the Iraqis as their very fragile government tries to survive just one day at a time. What strategy will the insurgents play? Only time will tell.
Did we win? Now that’s an interesting question. Can you win a war that was begun under false pretenses? Can you win a war that was started by a president of the United States who chose to either believe pure fantasy about a huge cache of weapons that never existed to begin with, or knowing they didn’t exist, fabricated a horrible lie, colluding with the officers of his administration do give the appearance that we were in state of a clear and present danger?
Since the evidence points to the president’s lying to the nation, an act of duplicity for which he will never have to face justice and neither will the officers who assisted him in constructing this completely false rationale for going to war, how, then, can we say that we won the war?
Started on False Pretenses, Ended on…?
What we did was topple a regime. We sought out an admittedly tyrannical dictator who oppressed his people, and let his sons run amok terrorizing any one they wished, simply on a whim. The fact that all three of them are dead was a gift to the Iraqi people. But the fact the war we brought to them cost the lives, according to the organization, Iraq Body Count, of between 97,267 and 106,146 civilians as well as the deaths of over 4400 military Americans. Many of these troops were killed trying to dodge the bullets and IEDs of a no-holds-barred civil war between rival tribal and religious sects of the same religion. This circumstance lasting years does not leave one with a sense that our goals lined up with theirs. And on both accounts, those numbers do not include the number of those wounded, maimed, left without spouses, or orphaned.
The truth remains that despite the last Stryker Brigade rumbling across the border into Kuwait, the war is not over. 50,000 U.S. troops will continue on for years to come. One Iraqi official stated: “If I were asked about the withdrawal, I would say to politicians: the U.S. army must stay until the Iraqi army is fully ready in 2020,” said the Iraqi military’s most senior officer Lt. Gen. Babakir Zebari last week.
Operation New Dawn is not the end of the war. It is a new phase. More Iraqis will die. More Americans will die. The jury of historical success or failure must remain silent for years to come. But some facts are already self-evident, and
both the United States and the Iraqis have paid a terrible price for the decision of one man who out of spite, a twisted sense of revenge, incompetence, delusion, or unmitigated stupidity, started the war and conned a nation into going along with it. While the two men and their henchmen remain free who we should have focused on like a laser beam to bring the down, to put a halt to the horrible
carnage they continue to spread around the world, a thousand opportunities were squandered by that administration to end the reign of terror those men and to pay for their murderous crime against the American people. For that, George Bush, 43rd president of the United States, should be forever judged most harshly.
But What of Hope?
The old saying goes, “You can’t make a silk purse out of a sow’s ear.” But sometimes through dogged determination, one can take the worst possible situation, and through hard work and creative thinking and planning bring some degree of good out of the bad.
This will be the paradox of the Iraqi war. For all the wrong reasons we invaded Iraq. The people our leaders believed would welcome us instead hated us even more. The people freed from the masochism of Saddam Hussein instantly split from the suppressed religious and tribal fractures that Saddam had used constant brutality to hold together to control his regime. We unleashed a monster of internecine savagery, an unintended consequence for which our leaders were totally unprepared or had any contingency to deal with. For years we, the great liberators, were literally trapped by the rage going on around us, trying to bring order in a nation so spiritually shattered that they wanted to kill us so that they could kill each other more quickly.
Despite all that…despite all that, the soldiers of a handful of countries that came to stand beside us, and our American troops, figured out ways to bring hope to the Iraqis. A million mistakes were undoubtedly made, but we are a people, or should I say a coalition, that don’t give up that easily. Yes, the other countries withdrew their forces, including the British, who had been the second largest contingent, before the fighting was truly over. But to their defense, many of their leaders saw the obvious and clear turning of events in Afghanistan, and moved their resources to that troubled land, where now they continue to fight alongside of our forces as they attempt to save Afghanistan from another Taliban regime, capable of a brutality that exceeds anything Saddam could have dreamed of many times over.
As the combat troops left last night, the question very much remains whether Iraq, is truly ready to embrace the new dawn our military has so optimistically chosen to call the next phase of the mission. The answer may be that it ends in collapse and civil war, where millions might die this time. It is my prayer that will not be the result, but I cannot predict the future. It appears though that the sheer hatred the Iraqis demonstrated against the U.S. at the time of the invasion has tempered. Though the rivers of mistrust of Americans and that the majority are Christians, runs deep, as the years have passed and the combat operations and firefights have subsided, our soldiers have had the chance to show the humanity that exists beneath the uniform.
Perhaps the chance to be human, to show kindness and even respect, after so many years of fighting has turned out to be irresistible to both the Americans and the Iraqis.
If that is true, then there is hope.